NewsCore
    VeilleFranceStratégieSouverainetéIntelligence

    Economic espionage: what legal qualification?

    In France, economic espionage is not covered by a specific criminal offence, despite the civil protection of trade secrets introduced in 2018. The offence voted by the Senate was dropped, and prosecution relies on related offences.

    18 February 20263 min read
    Economic espionage: what legal qualification?

    Economic espionage refers to intrusive and clandestine actions, often outside the bounds of legality, carried out to gain a strategic or economic advantage through manipulation, corruption or the theft of sensitive information. Yet its legal contours remain poorly defined, in Europe as in France. This article takes stock of the situation under French law.

    An offence that does not exist as such

    In France, economic espionage is not punished as a stand-alone offence. For an offence to be committed, the means used must themselves be illegal, as the law firm Cabinet ACI points out. Its direct prosecution therefore remains difficult, even though French companies are exposed to attempts to capture strategic information, which the State strives to prevent through an economic security policy led in particular by the SISSE, which is tasked with protecting strategic assets against foreign threats.

    Trade secrets, a civil-law protection

    The adoption of European directive 2016/943 of 8 June 2016, followed by law no. 2018-670 of 30 July 2018 transposing it, was a step forward. The law inserted into the French Commercial Code a title devoted to trade secrets (articles L. 151-1 et seq.): protection covers information that is not generally known, that has commercial value because it is secret, and that is subject to reasonable protective measures. The text also provides for exceptions, notably for freedom of expression and information and for the good-faith disclosure of an illegal activity. Declared consistent with the Constitution on 26 July 2018, the law was published in the Official Journal on 31 July, as the Senate's legislative file recounts.

    But this framework is essentially civil: it makes it possible to obtain an end to the infringement and compensation, without a stand-alone criminal component.

    The offence voted by the Senate, then dropped

    A specific offence nearly came into being, however. During the examination of the bill, the Senate had introduced, on the initiative of its law committee, an offence of economic espionage punishing the misappropriation of protected information for exclusively economic purposes, excluding journalists, whistleblowers and employee representatives from its scope. The joint committee of 24 May 2018 removed it, the Assemblée nationale rapporteur considering its introduction premature "in favour of a later joint reflection on criminal penalties for breaches of trade secrets", according to the Senate press release. The chairman of the law committee, Philippe Bas, had then regretted a "timid decision".

    Related offences, used case by case

    In the absence of a dedicated offence, the courts rely on related offences. Cabinet ACI cites breach of trust (article 314-1 of the Criminal Code, punishable by five years' imprisonment and a fine of 375,000 euros), theft (article 311-1), which case law has accepted can apply to data, and private corruption (article 445-2, five years' imprisonment and a fine of 500,000 euros, an amount that can be raised to twice the proceeds of the offence). When the information is handed over to a foreign power, offences against the fundamental interests of the nation, which include its economic and scientific potential, may be invoked. These tools nevertheless remain poorly suited to the capture of information by means that are not in themselves unlawful.

    The article's conclusion stands: a criminal offence suited to economic espionage still needs to be created to fill this gap, and the reflection announced in 2018 has not yet come to fruition.

    What monitoring teams should watch

    • Bills and amendments aimed at creating a criminal penalty for breaches of trade secrets, to be tracked through dedicated legislative monitoring.
    • Court decisions handed down on the basis of trade secrets and related offences, which clarify the effective protection of companies; they fall under legal monitoring.
    • Alerts from the SISSE and the intelligence services on economic interference methods, and intrusion signals picked up by cyber risk monitoring.
    • European developments in economic security, which could revive the debate on a common offence.

    Sources

    Go deeper

    All reports

    Three NewsCore reports that build on this article.